Dec 15

final-jur-e headline

Does Jury Verdict Offer Big Tech Critics a Path to Victory?

The Washington Post reports that video game maker Epic Games’ recent victory over Google in an antitrust suit may point to a new strategy for future challengers hoping to take on big tech. Earlier this week, a jury decided that Google’s app store – Google Play – constituted an illegal monopoly. This comes after Epic lost a similar battle against Apple to have its app store deemed a monopoly. Samuel Weinstein, a professor at the Cardozo School of Law, said of Epic’s win “If I was thinking about suing Google, I might think this is evidence that juries can be convinced to fight against Google.” The author opines that jurors may be more akin to everyday consumers rather than judges who are well-versed in competition policy.

Tis' the Season for Jury Scammers

As the holiday season ramps up, jury scammers are increasing their efforts to swindle targets out of money. The Center for Jury Studies at NCSC has a Jury Scam Toolkit available here and free posters that courts can display at the courthouse and provide to local government agencies, transportation hubs, drug stores, etc. If interested in these posters, please contact Paula Hannaford-Agor with your name, mailing address, and the number of posters you would like shipped.

FL Bill Could Excuse New Mothers from Jury Service

Fox35 Orlando reports that the Florida legislature is considering a bill that would excuse some women from jury service. The bill, filed by Rep. Caroline Amesty, would permit women who have given birth fewer than six months before being summoned for jury service to be excused. The House Civil Justice Subcommittee voted unanimously to approve the potential law; if enacted, it would go into effect beginning on July 1, 2024.

Hunter Biden's Mounting Charges Show High Cost of Exercising Right to Jury Trial

Reason, a self-described libertarian magazine founded in 1968, reports that Hunter Biden’s growing legal challenges showcase the imposing prosecutorial power to coerce plea deals and to dissuade defendants from exercising their jury trial right. Earlier this year, Special Counsel David Weiss announced that the president’s son would plead guilty to two misdemeanor tax offenses and in exchange, prosecutors would recommend dropping Biden’s felony gun charge after completing a two-year pretrial diversion program. This plea deal fell apart after judicial scrutiny. Since then, more charges have been brought against him. Author Jacob Sullum points out that Biden has gone from facing no time behind bars under the plea deal to now facing up to 42 years in federal prison for forcing the government to prove its case to a jury. Biden is not the exception.  According to one study by the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, the average sentence for federal defendants who were convicted at trial was more than three times as long as federal defendants who plead out.

Save The Date for the NCSC Jury System Management Workshop!

Taking place February 14-16, 2024 in Austin, Texas, the National Center for State Courts and the Travis County District Clerk are co-sponsoring the Jury System Management Workshop. Participants will learn about best practices to improve the efficiency and cost-effectiveness of jury operations, to ensure the integrity of the jury selection process, and to treat jurors with dignity and respect.  Capacity is limited to 45 participants. Courts are encouraged to bring teams if possible. Trial court systems that include limited, general, and special jurisdictions have benefited from this program in addition to municipal, city, district, and county courts. If you would like to attend, please fill out this interest form, and we will send you the registration link once it becomes available. For more information, you can email Laney Snyder at  or Paula HannafordAgor.